Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    International UN talks on controlling use of autonomous weapons collapse | Weapons technology

    Letby trial doctor barred from treating patients was expert witness in another case | Lucy Letby

    ‘No means no, however we dress and wherever we go’: 50 years of campaigning against rape | UK criminal justice

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    Naija Global News |
    Saturday, November 21
    • Business
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Science
    • Sports
    • Education
    • Social Issues
    • Technology
    • More
      • Crime & Justice
      • Environment
      • Entertainment
    Naija Global News |
    You are at:Home»Science»Readers reply: Why aren’t more animals hermaphrodites? | Life and style
    Science

    Readers reply: Why aren’t more animals hermaphrodites? | Life and style

    onlyplanz_80y6mtBy onlyplanz_80y6mtOctober 27, 2025003 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Readers reply: Why aren’t more animals hermaphrodites? | Life and style
    Two giant African snails before mating.
    Photograph: Albert Yarullin/Getty Images/iStockphoto
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Why aren’t more animals hermaphrodites? Snails and worms seem to have been successful using that method for sharing genes between any two individuals, but vertebrates evolved away from it. Why? Janet Lesley, Kent, UK

    Send new questions to nq@theguardian.com.

    Readers reply

    Because it takes all the fun out of courtship. Richard Orlando

    The question is based on a misperception. Big chunks of the phylogenetic tree of animals are hermaphroditic. There is a distinction between simultaneous hermaphroditism, where two different gonads occur in the same animal at the same time, and other forms of hermaphroditism called sequential where an animal can morph from male to female or vice versa. If you take together all these, this is a lot of animals and most angiosperm plants, too. It shows you how narrow or cultural and human perceptions are and how divorced from facts they are. This is one of the beauties of science, that it allows you to correct those misperceptions in a structured way. Whomightitbe

    For life forms where finding a mate is relatively easy, it is massively more beneficial to specialise into dimorphism to optimise traits, either female or male. For a life form with access to limited resources, to invest those in both systems is expensive and does not bring as much advantage. Niclas Ulfeldt

    While common garden snails are hermaphroditic, not all molluscs are. Some are sequential hermaphrodites, but many have separate sexes and exhibit extreme sexual dimorphism, such as the paper nautilus [a species of octopus]. Investment in eggs often requires a larger body size, or at least larger female cells. If the female has to care for the eggs or young, this also requires more investment in growth. I suspect there is a link between hermaphroditism and lifespan, and whether the animal is viviparous or oviparous. JaneTheSnail

    Wait. Are you telling me that Brian from The Magic Roundabout wasn’t a bloke? EddieChorepost

    No. He was both! Brutha

    It seems to me that most biology is based upon opportunistic evolutionary chance, mutation and the conditions in which that organism finds itself. Nature is not picky – it goes to the limits of possibility in all areas of life, hence the production of, for example, the most extraordinary deep sea creatures. But nor does it “care” about consequences. It’s not logical in any terms the human brain can conceive. Though “why” is my favourite question, I don’t believe in this instance there is a single answer. LorLala

    Gonochorism [a system where there are two sexes and each individual organism is either male or female] is more fun 🙂 SylDaiPou

    Predictably, this question seems to have triggered some mildly humorous answers. The possibility this is pure evolutionary chance perhaps seems a bit threatening to our sense of sexual identity. However, the good news is there is a solid scientific reason why more advanced animals will be of either one sex or the other. Having reproductive organs of either kind places a metabolic drain on an individual. Any individual having both types simultaneously doubles that load, and thus puts the individual at a significant survival disadvantage. Thus the force of evolution will, even if only marginally, favour a form which is sexually dimorphic rather than hermaphroditic. Rejennyrated

    Animals Arent hermaphrodites life readers reply style
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleAccel and Prosus team up to back early-stage Indian startups
    Next Article The Company Making a Mockery of State Gambling Bans
    onlyplanz_80y6mt
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Former American Idol contestant and pastor sentenced to life in prison for murdering his wife | US news

    October 5, 2026

    Catholic priest given life sentence for sexual assault in Texas found to have neglected daughter | New Orleans clergy abuse

    October 5, 2026

    The one change that worked: I was terrified of the dentist – until I found a very special one | Life and style

    September 14, 2026
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    The science influencers going viral on TikTok to fight misinformation

    February 17, 20263 Views

    MPs vote against legalising assisted dying in England and Wales | Assisted dying

    September 11, 20262 Views

    The backlash to revelations of sexual torture of Palestinian prisoners aims to raise the cost of speaking out | Yuli Novak

    May 14, 20262 Views
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Latest Reviews

    At Chile’s Vera Rubin Observatory, Earth’s Largest Camera Surveys the Sky

    By onlyplanz_80y6mtJune 19, 2025

    SpaceX Starship Explodes Before Test Fire

    By onlyplanz_80y6mtJune 19, 2025

    How the L.A. Port got hit by Trump’s Tariffs

    By onlyplanz_80y6mtJune 19, 2025

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest tech news from FooBar about tech, design and biz.

    Most Popular

    The science influencers going viral on TikTok to fight misinformation

    February 17, 20263 Views

    MPs vote against legalising assisted dying in England and Wales | Assisted dying

    September 11, 20262 Views

    The backlash to revelations of sexual torture of Palestinian prisoners aims to raise the cost of speaking out | Yuli Novak

    May 14, 20262 Views
    Our Picks

    International UN talks on controlling use of autonomous weapons collapse | Weapons technology

    Letby trial doctor barred from treating patients was expert witness in another case | Lucy Letby

    ‘No means no, however we dress and wherever we go’: 50 years of campaigning against rape | UK criminal justice

    Recent Posts
    • International UN talks on controlling use of autonomous weapons collapse | Weapons technology
    • Letby trial doctor barred from treating patients was expert witness in another case | Lucy Letby
    • ‘No means no, however we dress and wherever we go’: 50 years of campaigning against rape | UK criminal justice
    • Campaigners back call for scrutiny of consent laws by Joanne Young | Sexual consent
    • Bring in ‘cosmetic cowboys’ law to avoid more deaths, says family of butt lift victim | Health
    © 2026 naijaglobalnews. Designed by Pro.
    • About Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.