Polanski faces challenge to be Greens’ candidate for Holborn and St Pancras, as most Greens on local council back rival
Peter Walker
Peter Walker is a senior Guardian political correspondent.
Zack Polanski is facing unexpected internal opposition in his bid to fight the Holborn and St Pancras byelection for the Greens, with a local councillor saying he is also seeking the nomination and that the seat needs a local MP, not “a politician you’ll only see on a leaflet”.
Hamza Chowdhury, a Green councillor on Camden council in north London, said in a post that he had received nomination from six other Greens, meaning seven of the 10 Greens on the council oppose Polanski being selected.
Among those backing him is Lorna Russell, the group leader in Camden for the Greens, who are the official opposition to Labour.
Polanski, the leader of the Greens in England and Wales, announced on Thursday that he would seek the nomination to fight the seat vacated by Keir Starmer, setting up a high-stakes byelection against Labour.
Local party members will vote later this week to select a candidate, and the Guardian has been told that they are broadly supportive of Polanski standing.
But such high-profile opposition is notable, especially given Chowdhury argued that Polanski, who currently lives in east London, would be unable to properly represent the area if he won.
Chowdhury wrote on Instagram:
double quotation markI know Camden because I live it every day. I know the challenges facing our communities, our estates, our broken lifts, our unpicked bins, our unclean roads and endless housing register waiting list because these are the places I have grown up and continue to call home.
We don’t need another MP who arrives during an election campaign, puts out a few leaflets, makes a few promises and disappears once the votes are counted. We need an MP who is present, accessible and visibly part of the community all year round.
I am asking Green party members for the opportunity to represent your home truly and properly. I’m not asking you to vote for a politician you’ll only see on a leaflet. I’m asking you to choose someone who is already here.
Zack Polanski (second from left) campaigning in Holborn and St Pancras at the weekend with Green party activists. Photograph: Andy Hall/The GuardianShare
Updated at 09.30 EDT
Key events
15m ago
Lib Dems claim local government reorganisation could put ‘essential services and vulnerable people at risk’
22m ago
Farage claims Reform UK triggered council reorganisation U-turn by using judicial review court challenges
35m ago
List of counties and areas in England where local government reorganisation plans have been cancelled or shelved
1h ago
No 10 refuses to deny report saying the Sun won’t be getting any favours from Burnham while he’s PM
2h ago
Labour moves writ for Holborn and St Pancras byelection to be held on Thursday 8 October
2h ago
Rayner cancels some local government reorganisation plans for England, and delays others, after Burnham requested rethink
3h ago
MP calls for circumcisions by non-health professionals to be banned, as Commons debates amendments to health bill
3h ago
Polanski faces challenge to be Greens’ candidate for Holborn and St Pancras, as most Greens on local council back rival
3h ago
Policing minister Sarah Jones to make statement to MPs on Portsmouth anti-migrant disruption
4h ago
No 10 hits back at US ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, after he accuses UK government of ‘Jew hate’
4h ago
Opposition parties accuse Healey of offering ‘more of the same’ in his first major speech as chancellor
5h ago
Healey’s speech – snap verdict
5h ago
Ministers told to axe many consultations, and tolerate more legal risk, so they can drive through change more quickly
6h ago
Healey says he cannot comment on budget be because responding to speculation will ‘only fuel more speculation’
6h ago
Healey declines to rule out tax rises in budget
6h ago
Healey says he wants to cut burden of business regulation by 25%
6h ago
Healey says changes to Treasury’s green book rules will ‘skew investment to projects with more long-term potential’
6h ago
Healey allocates £150m from British Business Bank for start-ups in north of England
7h ago
Healey says he will set out ‘roadmap to fiscal devolution’ in budget
7h ago
Healey says he wants to ‘draw the line’ under ever-rising costs for business
7h ago
Healey says making ‘Great Britain growth Britain again’ is ‘central’ to his mission as chancellor
7h ago
Healey says there’s ‘nothing progressive’ about paying debt interest, and being ‘true to our values’ means controlling spending
7h ago
‘Even Reeves had more vision’ – opposition parties not impressed by advance briefing on Healey’s speech
7h ago
Healey says he wants growth story ‘written in more places’
8h ago
Minister condemns ‘thuggish’ far-right, anti-migrant protesters in Portsmouth
County councils in England were particularly opposed to the proposed local government reorganisation because county councils operate in a two-tier system (with district councils), and the main purpose of the plan was to replace two-tier councils with unitary councils (on the grounds they are supposedly more efficient).
Today the County Councils Network issued a broadly positive statement about the reorganisation U-turn. Its chair elect, Sean Matthews, said:
double quotation markMany of our members had serious concerns [about the reorganisation] and felt the decisions taken over the last six months would not deliver any of these aims – with the previous Starmer government shifting substantially from its own criteria to create new authorities covering populations of 500,000 or more. Others were concerned how decisions were made, the robustness of the process and the underpinning evidence.
The CCN called on the new administration in government to take ownership of the programme – reviewing the decisions made and only proceeding with proposals that can deliver sustainable councils and protect services. We are pleased they have taken ours, and our councils’ concerns on board by announcing a pause and review of the programme today.
Many of our members will be relieved that the decisions they viewed as damaging to local services and financially unsustainable have been withdrawn or are being reviewed. For our councils that do want to proceed with reorganisation in their area, we will support them in their next steps and we will be seeking further clarity from government in the coming days.
Share
Lib Dems claim local government reorganisation could put ‘essential services and vulnerable people at risk’
The Tories have described the government’s local government reorganisation U-turn as a “total humiliation”. David Simmonds, the shadow local government minister, said in a statement:
double quotation markThis is yet another total humiliation for this Labour Government, who have once again been exposed breaking the law in an attempt to force their top-down programme of local government reorganisation on communities.
Ministers are only backing off because they have been found out in the face of relentless Conservative opposition to their gerrymandering. Their behaviour shows that [Andy] Burnham and [Angela] Rayner’s promise to empower local communities is completely hollow: their intention was always to dictate downwards.
And, in her statement, Zöe Franklin, the Lib Dem local government spokesperson, says services are at risk.
double quotation markThis is an embarrassing and chaotic climbdown, which has resulted in already cash-strapped councils wasting huge sums on plans the government told them were legally watertight.
Many local authorities, on the frontline of delivering vital services such as adult social care and Send support, were relying on this reorganisation to survive financially. Many are now left with nothing, potentially putting essential services and vulnerable people at risk.
Share
Farage claims Reform UK triggered council reorganisation U-turn by using judicial review court challenges
Reform UK politicians are normally the first to complain about the courts being used to obstruct the wishes of an elected government. But Reform councils in Norfolk, Suffolk and Essex launched judicial review proceedings to block the local government reorganisation plans that were going to abolish those county councils and Nigel Farage, the party leader, has claimed that it was these moves that triggered the government U-turn announced today.
In a statement, Farage said:
double quotation markReform UK not only argued that this government’s plans for local government reorganisation were an unmitigated disaster, but we once again put our money where our mouth is.
Earlier this year we took on the government and forced them to give the vote back to millions of people after Labour tried to cancel democracy. Now, thanks to our judicial reviews in affected Reform-led councils, the government has backed down on their plans yet again.
Only Reform had the backbone to stand up to these reckless plans. This is yet another embarrassing defeat for Labour. Only Reform backs real democracy.
Share
List of counties and areas in England where local government reorganisation plans have been cancelled or shelved
Here is the list of the four counties where local government reorganisation plans have been scrapped: Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk and Suffolk.
And here are the 14 counties and areas where local government reorganisation plans have been put on hold pending a review.
Derby and Derbyshire
Devon, Plymouth and Torbay
East Sussex and Brighton
Gloucestershire
Hertfordshire
Kent and Medway
Lancashire, Blackburn with Darwen and Blackpool
Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland
Lincolnshire, North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire
Nottingham and Nottinghamshire
Oxfordshire and West Berkshire
Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent
Warwickshire
Worcestershire
There are two other areas where the government was considering reorganisation but had not yet taken a decision over a proposed way ahead: Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, and West Sussex. In these areas, reorganisation is also on hold.
Share
In the Commons, Angela Rayner, the communities secretary, has just given a statement about her plans to cancel some local government reorganisation plans, and to delay others. (See 2.20pm.) Lindsay Hoyle, the speaker, said it was relief to have an announcement that had not been briefed to the media in advance.
Share
On the subject of Liverpool, the Department for Transport has confirmed that Liverpool city region is getting £86m to bring its bus services under public control. In a news release, the DfT says:
double quotation markMillions of passengers across the Liverpool city region are set to benefit from better, more reliable bus services as the city becomes the first to bring its network under public control under this government.
In a huge boost for local growth, the government will provide £86.3m of funding until 2029 to deliver better services for passengers, as well as a share of a new one-off £3m pot to help mayors take control of their services.
This funding will give the combined authority the power to plan bus networks to run services where they are needed most. Like in London and Greater Manchester where bus services are franchised, this also means local leaders in Liverpool will have more say over routes, branding and fares, which could mean cheaper journeys across the city.
Share
No 10 refuses to deny report saying the Sun won’t be getting any favours from Burnham while he’s PM
Downing Street had refused to deny an Observer story saying that Andy Burnham intends to ensure that the Sun newspaper does not get any special editorial favours from him as PM.
That suggests Rupert Murdoch’s favourite tabloid won’t be getting exclusive interviews, or special articles for publication carrying Burnham’s byline.
The Observer report was written by Tom Baldwin, a former Labour communications director, who explained:
double quotation markAlthough neither Burnham nor his official spokespeople have said anything explicit since he entered No 10 about ending cooperation with the newspaper, three separate sources close to him have privately said he intends to maintain a stance of granting the tabloid “no special favours”.
His position is understood to be causing “consternation” within the headquarters of the newspaper’s owner, Rupert Murdoch’s News UK, where executives have long since been used to the Sun getting access and securing influence at the very highest level of government.
Burnham’s decision is understood to relate to the Hillsborough tragedy. He grew up near Liverpool and had friends who were at the Hillsborough match, and campaigning for justice for the families of victims became one of the big causes of his political career. As a young culture secretary, Burnham gave a speech at the Hillsborough 20th anniversary memorial in 2009 which was instrumental in persuading him that the government had to redouble its efforts to ensure the full truth came out.
No paper did more to smear the Hillsborough fans than the Sun, which falsely claimed that their behaviour was to blame for the crush that led to 97 people being killed. Although the paper has apologised, and all those involved in that reporting have long since moved on, the paper is still reviled on Merseyside.
Asked about the Observer story at the Downing Street lobby briefing, the PM’s spokesperson did not deny the claim that the Sun would not be getting special favours from the new PM. Asked repeatedly about the story, the spokesperson just said that Burnham would be engaging “with a wide range of media, including new forms of media”, as he has been doing already.
Share
Lucy Powell, the deputy Labour leader, has issued this statement following the moving of the writ for the Holborn and St Pancras byelection. (See 2.41pm.)
double quotation markLabour has hit the ground running in Holborn and St Pancras. We’ve been out every day speaking to local residents about their priorities and it’s clear that Andy Burnham’s message of hope is really cutting through. Since this byelection was announced we’ve had thousands of conversations on the doorstep right across the constituency and Labour activists and supporters will be speaking to thousands more in the coming days.
While others talk, Labour is delivering the progressive change people in Holborn and St Pancras want to see. We’ve taken early action to give people vital breathing space on the cost of living, and we’re taking on the long term challenges people really care about, like ending rough sleeping, tackling youth unemployment and making sure we finally fix our social care system.
Share
In the Commons Rishi Sunak, the former prime minister, has just asked a question during questions to the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government. Florence Eshalomi, the homelessness minister, was replying and, in a pointed jibe about Keir Starmer, she said it was good to see a former PM still playing an active role in the Commons.
Share
Labour moves writ for Holborn and St Pancras byelection to be held on Thursday 8 October
In the Commons Anneliese Midgley, the Labour chief whip, has just moved the writ for the Hoborn and St Pancras byelection. That means it will be held on Thursday 8 October.
Share
Rayner cancels some local government reorganisation plans for England, and delays others, after Burnham requested rethink
Decisions on flagship local government reorganisation have been withdrawn as the government launches a review of the plans following new legal advice, the Press Association reports. PA says:
double quotation markThe Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) said the review is to ensure the process is robust and aligns with the new government’s aim to “rewire the state”, and follows “updated and privileged legal advice”.
At least eight councils have launched legal challenges or were considering to do so due to opposition to the government’s choice of footprints for new councils.
Reform UK-led Kent county council is set to consider a judicial review at a meeting on Tuesday after it did not receive a response from the government to a letter setting out concerns.
Plans for reorganisation in Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk and Suffolk have been withdrawn in the light of new legal advice.
Decisions on 14 further areas will be reviewed and paused alongside the cases of Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, and West Sussex, which are yet to have a decision confirmed.
The government will also confirm that local elections in May 2027 will go ahead on existing council boundaries, saying it remains committed to effective and sustainable local government and simplifying these structures.
Communities secretary Angela Rayner is expected to tell parliament on later: “As we are now more determined than ever to devolve power closer to the people we represent, it’s only right that as a new secretary of state I make sure that everything we do is working towards that plan to change Britain, without delay.
“The prime minister told the House last week he was ‘prepared to look at local government reorganisation’ and he asked me as his communities secretary to ‘do that’.
“In that context, in light of legal advice, I want to satisfy myself firstly that the right process is in place, that it is robust, and of course complies with the law.
“And, secondly, I want to fully test whether our proposals for local government reorganisation meet the priorities of a new administration and a new prime minister, and any additional considerations.
“I do not take this lightly. I recognise the huge amount of work that has already gone into progressing reorganisation in each of these areas and I am very grateful for it.”
MHCLG said reorganisation in Surrey will not be affected by the review and the two new unitary authorities, East and West Surrey, will go live in April 2027.
Share
MP calls for circumcisions by non-health professionals to be banned, as Commons debates amendments to health bill
Chris Osuh
Chris Osuh is a Guardian community affairs correspondent.
A proposal to ban anyone who is not a healthcare professional from performing circumcisions has been launched in parliament after the deaths of baby boys in the UK.
Sam Carling, Labour MP for North West Cambridgeshire, has tabled an amendment to the government’s health bill.
At present, anyone can legally circumcise in the UK. The amendment calls for non-therapeutic male circumcision to become a “regulated activity,” and follows coroner’s inquests and criminal prosecutions drawing attention to the risk of unregulated circumcisers.
Circumcision is routinely performed for religious and cultural reasons in some Black, Jewish and Muslim communities in Britain. Community organisations have been warning of the risks of the lack of regulation.
In a prevention of future deaths report published in January, the government was urged by a coroner to take action to avoid similar tragedies to the death of Mohamed Abdisamad, a baby who died of a streptococcus infection in February 2023, a week after being circumcised.
Since 2001, circumcision has been a factor in the deaths of seven boys.
Carling said:
double quotation markThe need to strengthen the regulation of non-therapeutic male circumcision could not be clearer. The tragic death of Mohamed Abdisamad in 2023, and other tragic deaths and serious injuries in recent years, have shown that the legal framework in this space is simply not good enough.
My amendment would enact the recommendations of the coroner in Mohamed’s case, who was clear that the status quo, in which anyone can perform a circumcision with no requirements on infection control measures or aftercare, would lead to future deaths.
Carling’s amendment would require circumcision to come under the inspection regime of the Care Quality Commission, and for integrated care boards to produce annual data on prevalence and complications of non- therapeutic male circumcision.
MPs will be debating report stage amendments to the health bill this evening, and it will get its third reading tomorrow.
Yvette Cooper, the new health secretary, is tabling a series of government amendments to the bill intended to strengthen local accountability and increase support for maternity services. Explaining the changes, a government source said:
double quotation markMandatory local government representation will be restored on the integrated care boards which manage health services around the country, reflecting Andy Burnham’s devolution agenda.
And a new role of maternity and neonatal commissioner will be created by the bill, reflecting Cooper’s personal prioritisation of maternity services and developed alongside the government’s maternity advisor Michelle Welsh (MP for Sherwood Forest).
Share
Updated at 08.59 EDT
Polanski faces challenge to be Greens’ candidate for Holborn and St Pancras, as most Greens on local council back rival
Peter Walker
Peter Walker is a senior Guardian political correspondent.
Zack Polanski is facing unexpected internal opposition in his bid to fight the Holborn and St Pancras byelection for the Greens, with a local councillor saying he is also seeking the nomination and that the seat needs a local MP, not “a politician you’ll only see on a leaflet”.
Hamza Chowdhury, a Green councillor on Camden council in north London, said in a post that he had received nomination from six other Greens, meaning seven of the 10 Greens on the council oppose Polanski being selected.
Among those backing him is Lorna Russell, the group leader in Camden for the Greens, who are the official opposition to Labour.
Polanski, the leader of the Greens in England and Wales, announced on Thursday that he would seek the nomination to fight the seat vacated by Keir Starmer, setting up a high-stakes byelection against Labour.
Local party members will vote later this week to select a candidate, and the Guardian has been told that they are broadly supportive of Polanski standing.
But such high-profile opposition is notable, especially given Chowdhury argued that Polanski, who currently lives in east London, would be unable to properly represent the area if he won.
Chowdhury wrote on Instagram:
double quotation markI know Camden because I live it every day. I know the challenges facing our communities, our estates, our broken lifts, our unpicked bins, our unclean roads and endless housing register waiting list because these are the places I have grown up and continue to call home.
We don’t need another MP who arrives during an election campaign, puts out a few leaflets, makes a few promises and disappears once the votes are counted. We need an MP who is present, accessible and visibly part of the community all year round.
I am asking Green party members for the opportunity to represent your home truly and properly. I’m not asking you to vote for a politician you’ll only see on a leaflet. I’m asking you to choose someone who is already here.
Zack Polanski (second from left) campaigning in Holborn and St Pancras at the weekend with Green party activists. Photograph: Andy Hall/The GuardianShare
Updated at 09.30 EDT
The Sarah Jones statement about Portsmouth (see 1.18pm) will be the second of three ministerial statements this afternoon. There are no urgent questions.
At 3.30pm, before Jones, Angela Rayner, the communities secretary, will make a statement about local government reorganisation. That should last about an hour, and after Jones finishes, at about 5.30pm, Emma Reynolds, the chief secretary to the Treasury, will make a statement about economic growth.
Share
Policing minister Sarah Jones to make statement to MPs on Portsmouth anti-migrant disruption
At the Downing Street lobby briefing the PM’s spokesperson condemned the behaviour of anti-migrant protesters who blocked roads in Portsmouth yesterday. He said: “Thuggish behaviour is unacceptable, we condemn it unreservedly.”
This was stronger than the initial response released by the Home Office yesterday, but in line with what Emma Reynolds, the chief secretary to the Treasury, said in interviews this morning. (See 8.59am.)
Sarah Jones, the policing minister, will give a statement to MPs on the disruption later this afternoon.
Asked if the government regarded the protests as “far-right”, the PM’s spokesperson said that dealing with them was an operational matter for the police, but that “any behaviour that is intimidatory and a cause of disruption to passengers and travellers is unacceptable”.
Share
No 10 hits back at US ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, after he accuses UK government of ‘Jew hate’
At the weekend Mike Huckabee, the US ambassador to Israel, posted this on social media about the UK.
double quotation markThe Brits have lost it. The Jew hate of their government knows no boundaries and knows no facts
Huckabee was commenting on a tweet from the Israeli government criticising Ed Miliband, the foreign secretary, for comments about Israel’s record in Gaza.
Asked about Huckabee’s comment at the Downing Street lobby briefing, the PM’s spokesperson said:
double quotation markWe completely reject that assertion. We’re committed to protecting Jewish communities in the UK and continue to engage with community leaders and groups.
The government is investing almost £380m over three years, to protect Jewish communities, crack down on antisemitic extremism and hostile state activity, and tackle antisemitism in schools, universities and local communities.
The spokesperson would not say if the government had formally complained to the US authorities about Huckabee’s remark.
Share
Jaguar Land Rover has announced thousands of job cuts in a “body blow for workers” as it grapples with tough trading conditions, Donald Trump’s tariff wars and the fallout from a cyber-attack. Rob Davies and Alex Daniel have the story.
Asked about this at the No 10 lobby briefing, the PM’s spokesperson said:
double quotation markWe understand that this will be an uncertain and concerning time for affected workers, their families and the wider communities.
And we know that current market conditions are challenging for the automotive sector globally. That’s why we’ve taken significant action to back the UK’s automotive industry by lowering electricity bills for manufacturers, providing £4bn of capital R and D funding to manufacture zero-emission vehicles and launching a £2bn electric car grant to encourage people to buy Evs.
The business secretary [Jonathan Reynolds] is in close contact with JLR and he will be meeting them early this week.
The spokesperson also confirmed that Reynolds has been “clear on his ruling out of any form of bailout”.
Share
Hamish Falconer, appointed by Andy Burnham as minister for EU relations, has had his first official meeting with his EU opposite number, Maroš Šefčovič. In a social media post, Falconer says he wants “a more ambitious partnership”.
Share
