Rayner urges government to be more ‘unapologetically Labour’
The leasehold announcement is an example of what Angela Rayner, the former deputy PM and former housing secretary, meant when she said at a fundraising event last night that the government should be more “unapologetically Labour”.
In its manifesto, Labour said:
We will take further steps to ban new leasehold flats and ensure commonhold is the default tenure. We will tackle unregulated and unaffordable ground rent charges.
Given the government has a manifesto mandate for what it is proposing today (see 8.57am), the announcement should not come as a surprise. But it has impressed campaigners because the property sector lobbying against the move was so strong that ministers started to have second thoughts. That is why the decision has been repeatedly delayed. When he was housing secretary, Michael Gove wanted to get rid of ground rents altogether, but he also enountered pushback and he failed to overcome Whitehall/government resistance to the idea.
In their London Playbook briefing for Politico, Andrew McDonald and Bethany Dawson report that, at a Labour fundraising event last night, Rayner said the government should be more Labour. She said:
We’ve done a lot of really good things. But my diagnosis of what’s gone wrong is that people think we’ve got there through being pushed there, as opposed to people thinking that that’s what we stand for and believe. I think that we need to be unapologetically Labour.
Share
Key events
Show key events only
Please turn on JavaScript to use this feature
Wes Streeting, the health secretary, brought his party umbrella to Downing Street this morning. Maybe he was inspired by Angela Rayner’s speech about being “unapologetically Labour”. (See 9.27am.)
Wes Streeting leaving No 10 after cabinet this morning. Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PAShare
Manchester city council leader Bev Craig rules out standing to be Labour’s candidate in Gorton and Denton
Some Labour figures have already given up hope of the party winning the Gorton and Denton byelection, the Times reports. In its overnight story, it says:
A senior government figure told The Times: “Realistically we know that we’re going to lose. But it was a question of what was worse: losing a by-election or losing control of Greater Manchester, which would have been a total disaster.
The Labour MP John Slinger has criticised this sort of briefing. In a post on social media commenting on this quote, he said:
Labour people should be booking their train to the Gorton & Denton by-election and knocking on doors in support of whoever is selected and our party, not speculating about losing or perpetuating the psychodrama.
At one stage there was speculation that Bev Craig, the Labour leader of Manchester city council, might apply to be Labour’s candidate. Last night she ruled herself out. She said:
It’s a privilege to lead such an incredible city and our @McrLabour Council. Building a better city & delivering for Mancunians.
I rarely comment on internal Labour matters but I am not seeking selection for the by-election. I will be working damn hard to elect a Labour MP
Share
As Dave Burke reports for the Daily Mirror, the Reform UK MP Lee Anderson posted a picture on social media of himself and activists campaigning in the Gorton and Denton byelection – standing outside a hotel that is actually in Angela Rayner’s neigbouring Ashton-under-Lyne constituency. Rayner told the paper: “Farage’s Reform can’t even find the Gorton and Denton constituency on a map. Perhaps it’s because they’re too busy filling their party full of former Tories who failed the country.”
Share
Updated at 06.35 EST
Mala Tribich (centre, with David Lammy sitting on her left and Keir Starmer on her right), a Holocaust survivor, addressing a cabinet meeting this morning to mark Holocaust Memorial Day. Photograph: Alastair Grant/PAShare
Freehold investors should get compensation for ground rents being capped, says British Property Federation
The British Property Federation has said that the government’s plan to cap ground rents could discourage investment into the UK. It is also saying that landlords should get compensation. In a response to the announcement this morning (see 8.57am), Danny Pinder, director of policy at the BPF, said:
While we agree that rapidly escalating ground rents should be addressed, the proposed cap will interfere with investments made by pension funds and institutional investors over many years and undermine the government’s pursuit of investment in this country. The various documents published by the government today make clear that these changes will have an impact on freeholders – the value of their assets and their ability to match index-linked pension liabilities – but that they intend to proceed, nonetheless. We have long been clear that adequate compensation must be provided to these entities as they have invested in good faith in order to meet their liabilities and continue to fund everyone’s pensions – today’s announcements is silent on that point …
There are billions of pounds invested in large-scale residential and mixed-use developments, and it is essential that reform is mindful of the rights of property owners as well as leaseholders. In our legal system contract is sacrosanct and legislative changes that cut across and undermine existing commercial agreements will raise the risk premium that investors attach to the UK at a time when the government is seeking to attract domestic and private capital for its growth agenda.
Share
Lib Dems call for ‘absurd, feudal system of leasehold’ to be abolished for good
Like the Greens (see 9.09am), the Liberal Democrats are also saying leasehold should be abolished for good. This is from Gideon Amos, the Lib Dem housing spokesperson, commenting on the government’s announcement this morning.
This news will come as a relief for thousands of leaseholders who have had their finances wrecked by spiralling ground rents.
But the government cannot call this job done. Liberal Democrats demand an end to the absurd, feudal system of leasehold for good.
People are being fleeced by a system that restricts their rights in a way that is indefensible in the 21st century.
Share
Keir Starmer’s TikTok video about capping ground rents has been viewed by about 20,000 people. Much more popular is a video of Starmer impersonating (albeit rather half-heartedly) Emmanuel Macron, in a live interview last night with the political podcaster and comedian Matt Forde. Starmer was handed a pair of sunglasses, which he promptly put on, saying “Bonjour”. The clip has notched up more than 160,000 views. Starmer (or, more probably, his social media team) tagged Macron in the post, with the line “Talk to me, Goose”, a reference to the Top Gun movie which seemed to inspire the look Macron was modelling with the shades he was wearing at Davos.
Keir Starmer being interviewed by Matt Forde last night Photograph: TikTokShare
Blocking Andy Burnham from Gorton and Denton byelection ‘real gift’ to Reform UK, Labour MPs tell Starmer
Some Labour MPs have not given up trying to get the part to rethink its decision to ban Andy Burnham from being a candidate in the Gorton and Denton byelection.
As Pippa Crerar, Jessica Elgot and Peter Walker report in our overnight story, the executive of the soft-left Tribune group of MPs – which includes the former ministers Louise Haigh and Justin Madders and the select committee chair Sarah Owen – have told Shabana Mahmood, the chair of Labour’s national executive committee (NEC), that they are unhappy about the decision.
In a related development, around 50 Labour MPs have signed a letter to Keir Starmer saying that blocking Burnham is a “real gift” to Reform UK.
According to a report in the Mail, the letter says:
As a former cabinet member and the current Labour mayor of Greater Manchester, there is no legitimate reason why Andy Burnham should not have the democratic right to put his candidacy to the local people of Gorton and Denton.
This is particularly important as polling clearly shows he may be our very best chance at winning this byelection.
Nigel Farage also thinks that not having Burnham on the ballot is a gift to his party.
Share
Capping ground rents means landlords won’t be able to fund essential repairs, and some could go bust, lobby group claims
Investors in the property sector claim that, if ground rents are capped, landlords will no longer be able to fund essential repairs and some firms will go bust. These arguments are set out in a letter published yesterday from Natalie Chambers, director of the Residential Freehold Association, to Steve Reed, the housing secretary.
Here is an extract.
We have previously set out a range of wider concerns with a retrospective cap, including the impact on the UK’s reputation as a reliable place to invest following a government-sanctioned interference with the contracts on which investors rely – and the fact that any ground rent cap would, in the large part, transfer value from pensioners to wealthy overseas buy to let landlords. This letter is intended to address the specific effect of forcing insolvency upon the very organisations which your department is relying on to remediate unsafe buildings.
Ground rent income is a critical and irreplaceable funding mechanism, without which building owners would not be able to meet their statutory duties under the Building Safety Act. Specifically, our members’ ability to provide effective oversight and management of higher-risk buildings, and to enter into government-backed Grant Funding Agreements (GFAs) for remediation works.
Retrospectively removing or reducing the level of contractually payable ground rent, or the contractual reviews to the ground rent, will result in a significant number of professional freeholders being at risk of immediate insolvency. That, in turn, would immediately undermine the contracts and legal obligations that underpin the government’s building safety remediation programme, encompassing approximately 9,000 to 12,000 buildings and with an estimated cost of between £12.6bn and £22.4bn.
In ignoring these arguments, the government has in effect decided that the property sector is bluffing – and that the consequences won’t be as dire as they claim.
Share
Rayner urges government to be more ‘unapologetically Labour’
The leasehold announcement is an example of what Angela Rayner, the former deputy PM and former housing secretary, meant when she said at a fundraising event last night that the government should be more “unapologetically Labour”.
In its manifesto, Labour said:
We will take further steps to ban new leasehold flats and ensure commonhold is the default tenure. We will tackle unregulated and unaffordable ground rent charges.
Given the government has a manifesto mandate for what it is proposing today (see 8.57am), the announcement should not come as a surprise. But it has impressed campaigners because the property sector lobbying against the move was so strong that ministers started to have second thoughts. That is why the decision has been repeatedly delayed. When he was housing secretary, Michael Gove wanted to get rid of ground rents altogether, but he also enountered pushback and he failed to overcome Whitehall/government resistance to the idea.
In their London Playbook briefing for Politico, Andrew McDonald and Bethany Dawson report that, at a Labour fundraising event last night, Rayner said the government should be more Labour. She said:
We’ve done a lot of really good things. But my diagnosis of what’s gone wrong is that people think we’ve got there through being pushed there, as opposed to people thinking that that’s what we stand for and believe. I think that we need to be unapologetically Labour.
Share
Green party says government should ‘scrap leasehold altogether’
The Green party says the government should be going further on leaseshold, and getting rid of it altogether. This is from Zack Polanski, the Green leader.
Time for Government to stop tinkering around the edges and scrap leasehold altogether.
Share
Starmer ignores property investors’ protests and commits to capping leasehold ground rents at £250
Good morning. At 7am Keir Starmer announced a decision that will benefit millions of leaseholders. Ground rents are being capped at £250, which means that anyone paying more than that will save money. Perhaps more significantly, this will protect leaseholders living in properties where ground rent charges soar over time, making their homes hard to sell. The proposal is in a draft commonhold and leasehold reform bill.
While this may sound like a cost of living policy announcement of no particular interest to people who are not leaseholders, it is actually quite an important revealed preference moment for the Guardian. This announcement has been held up for months and months because of lobbying from the financial sector (channelled through the Treasury), who have argued that capping ground rents will hammer property investors, and even the pension funds that have money tied up in this sector. There have been been threats of legal action over the retrospective element of this legislation (which will apply to existing ground rent agreements, not just new ones). In a Guardian article about this last week, Angela Rayner, the former deputy PM and former housing secretary, said:
If Labour cannot fix such an obvious injustice and show families whose living standards have been crushed that we will fight for them, then we shouldn’t be surprised if they lose faith that anything can change.
This battle is a symbol of so much more. It is about whose side we are on, and who we are in government to fight for.
Today Starmer has sided with Rayner, leaseholders and the younger generation, against the Treasury and the financial sector. It is a significant moment.
Jamie Grierson has the story here.
Here is the government’s news release. And Starmer announced the decision this morning in a post on TikTok. According to No 10, this is the first time a PM has made a major government new announcement on this platform.
Steve Reed, the housing secretary, said:
If you own a flat you can be forced to pay ground rents that can become completely unaffordable. We said we’d be on the side of leaseholders – which is why today we are capping ground rent – helping millions of leaseholders by saving them money and giving them control over their home.
The leasehold system has tainted the dream of home ownership for so many. We are taking action where others have failed –strengthening home ownership and calling time on leasehold for good.
Under the draft bill, the government is also going to ban leasehold for new flats, and give existing leaseholders the right to switch to commonhold. (This briefing explains the difference.)
But it is only a draft bill. The government says the cap on ground rents is not likely to come into force until late 2028.
Here is the agenda for the day.
9.30am: Keir Starmer chairs cabinet.
11.30am: Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, takes questions in the Commons. She is expected to announce a £100m support package for pubs to compensate (at least in part) for the impact of higher business rate costs.
Noon: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing.
After 12.30am: Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, is expected to make a statement to MPs about the decision to cap ground rents.
2pm: The Reform UK Lee Anderson holds a press conference in Gorton and Denton where he will unveil the party’s byelection candidate.
2pm: John Healey, the defence secretary, gives evidence to the Commons defence committee.
Evening: Starmer leaves the UK for his trip to China.
If you want to contact me, please post a message below the line when comments are open (between 10am and 3pm), or message me on social media. I can’t read all the messages BTL, but if you put “Andrew” in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word.
If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @andrewsparrowgdn.bsky.social. The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary.
I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.
Share
Updated at 04.09 EST
